|
Mantras: are these repetitious phrases a valid tool in
reaching God?
In the Kundalini Yoga classes I attended, I was taught
that chanting mantras would aid in penetrating the supernatural and
achieving oneness with God. Yogi Bhajan compared God to a great computer
into which we could insert these ‘mystical formulas’ to obtain the
desired results. Our primary goal was enlightenment. The mantra we chanted
most often was "Ek Ong Kar, Sat Nam, Siri Wah Guru." In
essence the meaning is, "There is one God, Truth is his name and the
Great Spirit is our Teacher." The interpreted meaning of this mantra
suggests concepts far different within the Far Eastern worldview than it
does within the Christian worldview. In the latter, these are actually true
statements, however, the meanings of the phrases are altered significantly,
as the following comparisons reveal:
Ek Ong Kar—yes, there is "only one God,"
but there is "only one God" to the exclusion of all others. (See
Question #1)
Sat Nam—yes, "truth" is one of the names or titles of the
Lord, for Jesus claimed, "I am the way, the truth and the
life," but it is not his primary, personal name. (John 14:6) Furthermore,
the ‘truth’ proposed in Far Eastern religions is much different than the
actual truth revealed in Christianity.
Siri Wah Guru—yes, the Holy Spirit is sent into our
lives to "teach" us all things. (John 14:26) However,
according to biblical doctrine, we do not truly experience the ongoing
leadership and instruction of the Holy Spirit until we become "sons of
God" through the born again experience. (John 1:12) Also, the
Holy Spirit is the personal presence of God, not a mere impersonal, cosmic
force.
Supposedly by repetitiously chanting these words,
meditators can be supernaturally drawn into the reality of what the words
represent. Yogi Bhajan even claimed that repeating this particular mantra
creates "a special heat in which all the karmas get burned." Those
participating in this process "become neutralized."1 So
the highest purpose behind this practice is facilitating an earlier release
from the cycle of rebirths.
A mantra usually relates to a certain deity or embodies a
certain spiritual concept. Devotees of Mantra Yoga believe that if a mantra
centers on the name of a deity, chanting that mantra draws the spirit of the
meditator into intimate contact with that deity. Chanting a mantra that
speaks of a spiritual concept causes the ‘represented idea’ to pass from
the ‘conceptual’ into the ‘actual’ for the one meditating. Swami
Prabhupada of ISKCON (Krishna Consciousness) warns that unless a seeker is
"initiated by a bona fide spiritual master in the disciplic succession,
the mantra… received is without any effect."2 This is a
common belief among various swamis, gurus and Far Eastern religious belief
systems. There is little agreement, though, concerning which gurus are
actually ‘qualified’ to impart this knowledge.
Most advocates of this methodology believe the primal sound-vibration
uttered by the Infinite Oversoul was ‘OM,’ that this sacred word
accompanied the act of creation and continues to resound throughout the
entire cosmos. By echoing this subliminal vibration meditators can, in a
sense, ‘tune in’ to the origin of all things. An ancient Hindu text
declares, "When a Yogin is absorbed in the syllable OM, he becomes
eternal….He becomes one with Brahman….He wins absorption in Brahman, in
the supreme ultimate Self." (Markandeya Purana 39.6.16) One
source deepens the explanation, "OM is composed of the three
sounds A-U-M… which represent several important triads: the three worlds
of earth, atmosphere, and heaven; the three major Hindu gods, Brahma, Vishnu
and Shiva; and the three sacred Vedic Scriptures, Rg, Yajus, and Sama."3
In opposition to the theory that OM was the original
syllable spawning creation, the Bible teaches this happened because of a
number of easily understood commands given by God (See Genesis 1:1–26:
"Let there be light," "Let the dry land appear,"
"Let the earth bring forth," etc.). The Bible never suggests
that we should repetitiously chant those commands in order to achieve union
with God. Actually Jesus taught the opposite: that we should never use such
"vain repetitions" in prayer. (Matthew 6:7)
Every yoga teacher with whom I was associated insisted
Jesus studied under Indian gurus during his hidden years in order to
discover proper methods to awaken the Christ nature. If this were the case,
why did he return from the Far East only to warn others that such methods
were futile and should be rejected? Though he gave what has been called,
"The Lord’s Prayer," as a basic outline of effective prayer, he
never instructed those who subscribe to its use to sit for hours, repeating
these words over and over in a monotone voice. He never trained his
disciples in this kind of spiritual exercise and they never passed it on to
future generations of the church. If it were so important, certainly the
opposite would be the case.
Why are mantras an incorrect method of prayer? Primarily, because God is
not a mere energy force, to be manipulated or controlled in a mechanical way
by repeated word-formulas or incantations. We would never expect to make a
request of a fellow human being using such a technique. To do so would be
considered absurd. After monotonously repeating a request about a hundred
times, we would certainly be asked to remove ourselves from the premises.
Why should we think that God is responsive to such methodology? He is a
personal God to be approached from the heart in a personal way.
The Most High gives the invitation, "Call to Me, and
I will answer you, and show you great and mighty things, which you do not
know." (Jeremiah 33:3) In calling upon the Creator, it is not
only important to use right methods, but to use the correct name. Quite
often, mantras use names of gods who are not actual, existing entities, but
the product of human imagination. This automatically nullifies the
effectiveness of the practice and, worse than that, it opens the door to
deeper, spiritual deception.
In closing, I must admit that I do respect and appreciate the Far Eastern
perception of the power of words. Biblically this is an emphasis too. All
human beings are urged to "confess" with their lips and
"believe" in their hearts that God raised Christ from the dead in
order to experience true salvation. From that point forward, believers are
cautioned to hold the profession of their faith "without
wavering." For "death and life are in the power of the tongue and
those who love it will eat its fruit." (Romans 10:8–10, Hebrews
10:23, Proverbs 18:21)
Quoting the Word of God was the way Jesus defeated Satan
during his wilderness temptation. Confessing the promises of God is a
practice that believers are encouraged to prayerfully implement—and
sometimes confessing promises can become somewhat repetitive. However, these
practices are not the same as the Mantra Yoga method focused on reaching
enlightenment. Quoting and confessing God’s Word (after the initial
experience of salvation) is not a methodology aimed at becoming one with
God. Rather, it is the rightful exercise of a believer’s authority
resulting from that oneness with God he or she has already obtained as a
gift.
The Bible promises that God will ‘inhabit the praise of
His people.’ (See Psalm 22:3.) I admit that sometimes praise can be
repetitive, with certain statements being uttered often (e.g., "I love
you Lord," "I praise Your name," "I worship You,
Father," etc.). Once again, though, these are not mechanically repeated
formulas designed to bring a person into a state of enlightenment. These are
the celebration of a relationship already established. Even Mahatma Ghandi,
that great soul among Hindus, advised:
"Prayer…is a longing of the soul. It is a
daily admission of one’s weakness…It is better in prayer to have a
heart without words than words without a heart."4
Most anyone would agree that almost always, mantras
become "words without a heart."
1 Yogi Bhajan, The Teachings of Yogi
Bhajan, The Power of the Spoken Word, p. 173, #682.
2 A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, The
Science of Self Realization, p. 81.
3 "OM," Miriam-Webster’s Encyclopedia of
World Religions, p. 826.
4 The World’s Great Religions, p. 16, similar to
a quote by John Bunyan.
|